Section 5: Inferences, Hypotheses, Explanations¶

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Six sessions of building theories and testing explanations

Overview¶

The final section brings together all previous skills to focus on the ultimate goal of scientific thinking: constructing explanations that make sense of observations, patterns, and phenomena. You'll learn to distinguish between different types of explanations and develop skills in building, testing, and refining theoretical understanding.

The Nature of Scientific Explanation¶

What Makes a Good Explanation?¶

Coherence - fits together logically without contradictions
Parsimony - achieves maximum explanation with minimum assumptions
Testability - generates predictions that can be verified or falsified
Scope - explains a wide range of related phenomena
Precision - makes specific rather than vague predictions

Types of Scientific Explanations¶

Mechanistic - explains how something works step by step
Mathematical - describes relationships through equations and formulas
Analogical - explains unfamiliar phenomena in terms of familiar ones
Historical - explains current conditions through past events
Functional - explains why something exists in terms of what it accomplishes

Key Learning Activities¶

Multiple Working Hypotheses (Chamberlin Method)¶

Learning to: - Generate multiple explanations for the same phenomenon - Avoid premature attachment to single theories - Design tests that can distinguish between alternatives - Maintain objectivity by considering competing hypotheses simultaneously

Stacked Cantilevers Laboratory¶

A hands-on engineering challenge involving: - Theoretical prediction of optimal stacking arrangements - Experimental testing of theoretical predictions - Theory refinement based on empirical results - Collaborative problem-solving with betting and hypothesis competition - Mathematical modeling of physical phenomena

LoShu (Magic Squares) Investigation¶

Mathematical pattern investigation focusing on: - Complete theoretical understanding of mathematical structures - Systematic exploration of all possibilities - Elegant explanation of seemingly mysterious patterns - Proof construction and logical reasoning

Laws of Toy Universe Discovery¶

Collaborative laboratory exercise where the class discovers: - Hidden rules governing an artificial system - Hypothesis formation based on limited evidence - Experimental design for testing theories - Theory building through group collaboration - Scientific consensus formation

The Process of Theory Building¶

From Observation to Explanation¶

Careful observation - documenting what actually happens
Pattern recognition - identifying regularities and relationships
Question formulation - asking why patterns exist
Hypothesis generation - proposing possible explanations
Prediction derivation - determining what the hypothesis predicts
Experimental testing - checking predictions against reality
Theory refinement - modifying explanations based on results

Strong Inference (Platt Method)¶

A systematic approach to theory testing: - Devise alternative hypotheses for the same phenomenon - Design crucial experiments that can eliminate hypotheses - Carry out experiments with clear outcomes - Recycle the process with remaining hypotheses

Advanced Problem-Solving Exercises¶

The Miracle of FujiYama¶

A complex puzzle requiring: - Integration of multiple clues and constraints - Creative hypothesis formation - Systematic testing of possibilities - Collaborative reasoning and debate

Antigen Invasions¶

A biological modeling exercise involving: - Dynamic system analysis - Prediction of system behavior over time - Mathematical description of biological processes - Testing theoretical predictions against data

Martian DNA¶

An astrobiology thought experiment requiring: - Analogical reasoning from terrestrial biology - Creative hypothesis about alternative biochemistries - Logical consistency in theoretical constructions - Testable prediction generation

Bacterial Hybrids¶

A genetics problem involving: - Model construction for inheritance patterns - Statistical analysis of breeding data - Theory testing through prediction and verification - Scientific reasoning about unseen mechanisms

The Art of Scientific Reasoning¶

Types of Reasoning in Science¶

Deductive Reasoning: - From general principles to specific predictions - Logically certain conclusions from true premises - Mathematical proof and logical demonstration

Inductive Reasoning: - From specific observations to general principles - Probabilistic conclusions based on evidence - Pattern recognition and generalization

Abductive Reasoning: - Inference to the best explanation - Creative hypothesis formation - Choosing among alternative explanations

Avoiding Common Reasoning Errors¶

Confirmation bias - seeking only supporting evidence
Post-hoc reasoning - confusing correlation with causation
Overgeneralization - extending conclusions beyond valid scope
False dichotomy - considering only two alternatives when more exist
Ad-hoc modification - changing theories to save them from refutation

The Role of Prediction¶

Why Prediction Matters¶

Tests understanding - if you truly understand something, you can predict its behavior
Distinguishes theories - different theories often make different predictions
Guides research - predictions suggest new experiments and observations
Builds confidence - successful predictions increase theory credibility

Types of Scientific Predictions¶

Quantitative - specific numerical outcomes
Qualitative - general directions or trends
Existence - prediction of new phenomena or entities
Conditional - what will happen under specific circumstances

GameWorth Practice for Theory Building¶

Focus your daily sessions on:

Explanation generation - practice creating multiple explanations for phenomena
Prediction derivation - work out what your explanations predict
Critical evaluation - assess strengths and weaknesses of explanations
Theory integration - connect explanations to broader principles
Hypothesis testing - design ways to test theoretical predictions
Reflection on reasoning - analyze your own explanation-building process

Skills Being Developed¶

Theoretical Skills¶

Hypothesis construction from limited evidence
Logical reasoning and argument evaluation
Mathematical modeling of natural phenomena
Analogical thinking and metaphor construction

Critical Thinking Skills¶

Multiple hypothesis generation and maintenance
Crucial experiment design
Evidence evaluation and theory testing
Bias recognition and objectivity maintenance

Integration Skills¶

Synthesis of diverse observations into coherent explanations
Connection building between different areas of knowledge
Theory comparison and evaluation
Collaborative reasoning and consensus building

Assessment Focus¶

Your work will be evaluated on: - Quality of explanations you construct - Sophistication of reasoning in your GameWorth notebook - Ability to generate testable predictions from your theories - Effectiveness in collaborative theory-building exercises - Growth in explanatory power and theoretical thinking

Readings and Resources¶

Chamberlin: "Multiple Working Hypotheses" - the classic paper on avoiding theoretical bias
Platt: "Strong Inference" - systematic approach to theory testing
Judson, Chapter 7: "Strong Predictions" - the role of prediction in science
Judson, Chapter 9: "Theory" - how scientific theories develop and change
Feynman: "The Character of Physical Law" - insights into theoretical reasoning

Culminating Experience¶

This section concludes with comprehensive exercises that integrate all course skills: - Complex problem-solving requiring multiple approaches - Theory construction and testing - Collaborative discovery of fundamental principles - Reflection on learning and skill development throughout the course

The goal is to develop the ability to construct explanations that not only make sense of what you've observed, but also predict what you haven't yet seen - the hallmark of genuine scientific understanding.